Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Rode wet. Put away broke.'s avatar

Left you a message last week, here in Substack...

Expand full comment
A.P. Murphy's avatar

Though I continue to admire the enterprise of pushing the English sentence as far as it can go, I feel the length needs more variation sometimes. In previous installments you had a short-long-short-long rhythm and it worked really well. Here the long-long-long can be something of a chore, a slog. Though this matches well with your sisyphean theme, it imposes a high demand on the reader who might start reading another sentence and think "uh-oh, here goes another uphill climb". The short-long variation made the punchier bits like resting on a landing before the next flight of stairs.

Other than that I have an bone to pick with your narrator - not you personally, understand - who complains that the human heart "irresistibly imagines its leaders as oppressors and its blessings as burdens". But the overall drive of his musings is that the leaders *are* oppressors, and there are no blessings, only burdens.

Insofar as the coffeeshop boss is a leader, he has become an oppressor, because that system is the system we have in place, not co-operatives or workplace democracy in which the feeling is very very different. In those places - a simple co-op or a syndicated workplace - the human heart really is quite different, not boiling with resentment but brimming with empathy. But the coffeeshop enterprise is a hierarchy by its nature of owners vs workers, ergo the coffeeshop boss *is* a petty tyrant. That's not a reflection on the character of the boss, it's just how it is, structurally.

What I'm saying to Mr Narrator, not to you the writer, is that generalized misanthrophy, or Cioran-style misanthropy directed at yourself, is fine and even empowering in that paradoxical way that despair can become strength, but when punching downward at the unfortunate schmucks who have to work alongside or under you just comes off as mean. Not ennobling, just the rant of a tyrannized tyrant tyrannizing those even lower in the non-endowed sector of humanity where he himself dwells.

Hope you understand that the foregoing is all meant in the way of encouragement, not in any way a negative criticism. I love your work and its grimy pessimism, just that I feel the devastating force of the prose is best directed at self and world in general.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts