Discussion about this post

User's avatar
A.P. Murphy's avatar

"if there were 50,000 people on the planet we’d all be singing John Lennon and playing naked twister; larger population tend to hierarchize, divide, specialize and foment more intense status and resource competitions"

I completely disagree with this contention Caleb, as I expect you knew I would. It's true that large-scale societies require a great deal more *organization* - but organization is not necessarily hierarchical. Co-operative societies can operate without hierarchies, or with light hierarchies that are more guidelines than actual rules (pirate republics), or with turn-taking hierarchies in which I'm CEO today and toilet cleaner the next day.

It's just completely false that conflict requires the imposition of authority to sort things out. But just in case it does - how about police officer or private security guy for your next career move?

Expand full comment
Parappa's avatar

Enjoyed this a lot. Your job reminded me of a role I turned down because of too many red flags during the interview, essentially I was to be the 'IT guy', except the IT was outsourced. I asked them, 'what do you expect me to do all day if it's outsourced?' They said they didn't know, so the first half of this piece is how I imagined that would have went. I assume that role was some company 'signalling' about how they were 'improving IT' or whatever.

The second half re: psychology (I'm not clued up on psychology but I do know what it's like to work in a big company) reminds me of a behavioural psychologist I used to know who charges high fees to companies to basically make the drones work harder (I'm not calling them drones, more the company's perspective) as it's ultimately about KPIs. Anyway, she rattles on like what she's doing genuinely helps 'people' when in reality she's basically a kind of corporate high priestess, who, like you said, only exists to make them adapt to these systems at the company's behest. Fair enough 'it's a job', but she's internalised this 'empowerment' to such a level I'll be surprised if this false narrative she's perpetuating doesn't harm her mentally in the long run.

I've been in rooms with this 'alien speak' and they still do it even when you've known them for years, perhaps it's a cope or an abstraction, I'm sure many are good people.

Expand full comment
19 more comments...

No posts